In a stunning twist that could reshape the Dallas Cowboys’ offense for years to come, Jerry Jones and the front office are positioning themselves as the clear favorites to land one of the NFL’s most underrated running backs. Sources indicate that the Cowboys have emerged as the shock frontrunner in the pursuit of Atlanta Falcons’ Tyler Allgeier, the hard-nosed bruiser who exploded onto the scene with over 1,000 rushing yards in his rookie season. At 5-foot-10 and a rock-solid 225 pounds, Allgeier could be the hammer Dallas needs to pulverize defenses and elevate their ground game to elite status.
The Cowboys’ rushing attack roared back to life in 2025 under the new leadership of head coach Brian Schottenheimer and offensive coordinator Klayton Adams. After years of inconsistency, Dallas found rhythm on the ground, thanks in large part to free-agent acquisition Javonte Williams. The veteran back delivered a career-best performance, racking up 1,201 yards, 11 touchdowns, and an efficient 4.8 yards per carry. His 81.7 PFF rushing grade was a testament to how well he meshed with Adams’ zone-heavy scheme, which emphasized quick cuts, vision, and power between the tackles.
But with Williams now hitting free agency, the Cowboys face a crossroads. While both sides have expressed interest in a reunion, nothing is guaranteed in the cutthroat world of NFL contracts. Enter PFF analyst Mason Cameron, who has boldly pegged Dallas as the ideal landing spot for Allgeier in his latest free-agency breakdown. “The Cowboys saw a resurgence in their ability to run the football this season, a credit to Klayton Adams’ prowess in establishing the ground game,” Cameron wrote. “Williams turned out a career year; however, the depth behind him left much to be desired. With Williams scheduled to enter free agency – albeit with the possibility of returning to Dallas – the Cowboys should invest more into this backfield.”
Allgeier, a fifth-round steal out of BYU in the 2022 NFL Draft, has been quietly building a resume that screams “star in waiting.” As a rookie, he bulldozed his way to 1,035 rushing yards and three touchdowns, proving he could handle a heavy workload in Atlanta’s backfield. Since then, he’s played second fiddle to superstar Bijan Robinson, but don’t let the reduced snaps fool you—Allgeier has been lights-out efficient. Over the last two seasons, his 84.0 PFF rushing grade ranks among the top five qualifying running backs, and remarkably, he hasn’t fumbled once in that span. That’s the kind of ball security and reliability that Jerry Jones craves.
What makes Allgeier such a perfect fit for the Cowboys? It’s all about scheme synergy. Dallas leaned heavily on inside-zone runs in 2025, a concept that plays right into Allgeier’s strengths as a premier zone runner. His compact, powerful build allows him to explode through holes, absorb contact, and grind out tough yards after the initial hit. At 225 pounds, he’s got the mass to wear down defenses late in games, something the lighter Malik Davis (202 pounds) struggled with as a backup. Imagine Allgeier pairing with a re-signed Williams or stepping up as the lead back—Dallas could boast one of the league’s most physical and versatile tandems.
The Falcons, meanwhile, might be willing to part ways with Allgeier as they build around Robinson and navigate salary-cap constraints. Atlanta’s backfield has been crowded, and with Allgeier entering the final year of his rookie deal, a trade or free-agent move could net them assets while giving him a fresh start. For the Cowboys, this is Jerry’s big move—a chance to shock the NFL by snagging a proven producer without breaking the bank.
Fans in Dallas are already buzzing about the possibilities. Allgeier isn’t just a depth piece; he’s a potential game-changer who could push the Cowboys deeper into the playoffs. With Schottenheimer’s play-calling and Adams’ blocking schemes, this 1,000-yard bruiser could thrive in the Lone Star State, turning AT&T Stadium into a fortress on the ground.
Stay tuned—Jerry Jones doesn’t make small splashes. If the Cowboys pull this off, it could be the shock signing that propels them back to Super Bowl contention. How ’bout them Cowboys?
